One of my Etsy customers asked me to make these for a wedding.
I've had customers for the foam finger party pack ask me about real foam fingers (my party pack is miniature printable foam fingers, cupcake toppers and the like) but I couldn't come up with any good way to do it. Custom on foam, it seems all start with a quantity of at least 100. I spent a whole morning trying to come up with a way around it. When I stopped fixating on the material, I came up with these. They are not foam, they are faux foam(!) Ha, ha.
These are big (about 14 inches tall), you wear them over your hand just like a real foam finger, and they are completely recyclable when the party is over.
Making them is easy -- I send you the PDF, and you get them printed at a print shop on 11x17 paper. As many or as few as you need. Cut 'em out, glue the front and back together, and you're #1!
Check out my shop for the listing :)